No goddamn it.
This should not be. This was not meant to exist.
This thing should have not even been conceptualized.
Any session for this recording should be retroactively cancelled and erased from the memory of society.
It’s like the anti-rain cycle. Everything it does scientifically should have never reached a creative cloud in the first place. No evaporation, no condensation, no perspiration.
Don’t even show it to me on the 10 Day forecast, Mr. Weatherman.
I wouldn’t dare call this thing an album. That’d be insulting to all the hard-working albums with some depth. Most will at least give you some multiple feet. But Shaken ‘N’ Stirred? You’d struggle to get half a foot.
Noisy and incoherent, even good tracks like “Hip to Hoo” and “Too Loud” can only cruise until t-boned by Plant’s overindulgent production. Other tracks snooze at 20 mph before crashing musical sequiturs with all the impact of a paper car. Plant accelerated from solid to reckless, zero-to-100, in just three years.
That’s some Rod Stewart-type speed in abandoning what works for what glitters but has no gold. Weird poppy stage my ass, I start getting annoyed with artists that recklessly go pop.
I don’t dislike an artist that takes pop into consideration of their art. I don’t dislike it when Rod Stewart or Robert Plant put pop flourishes into their music. Just as I didn’t dislike Daft Punk for Random Access Memories.
And that’s because Daft Punk never went full-on disco—they made disco go full-on Daft Punk. Mixing disco instrumentation with classic house music structure.
In that vein, “In the Mood” and the rest of The Principle of Moments was pop fitting into Robert Plant’s trusted rock ‘n’ roll racer, worn and well while Shaken ‘N’ Stirred is Robert Plant fitting into a pop-mobile that’s neither his nor worn nor well.
Cross it out on the roadmap unless you’re into the whole “owning the entire discography” thing. Then you can join me in the van.
Meanwhile I’m taking “Little by Little” and “Sixes and Sevens,” and burning rubber from this album as fast as possible.
Quick Impressions: Not one of Robert Plant’s finer moments. Shaken ‘N’ Stirred’s only moments worth a real listen rest on the second side. Can we review Now and Zen yet?
Producer: Robert Plant
- “Hip To Hoo”
- “Kallalou Kallalou”
- “Too Loud”
- “Trouble Your Money”
- “Pink and Black”
- “Little By Little”
- “Doo Doo A Do Do”
- “Easily Lead”
- “Sixes And Sevens”